Headway UK responds to Milburn recommendations for young people

Any reforms to support young people into work or education must protect brain injury survivors and ensure they receive the financial and specialist support they need.

Exterior of the Palace of Westminster, London, in the evening

A government-commissioned review into the number of young people not in education, employment or training, known as the Milburn review, has been published. Its final report sets out recommendations aimed at reducing the proportion of 16-to-24-year-olds in this group from 13% to 5% by 2036.

Personal Independence Payment and Universal Credit changes

The report recommends removing eligibility for the Universal Credit health top-up for young people and introducing a Youth Allowance, set at the same rate as standard Universal Credit.

It also proposes replacing Personal Independence Payment (PIP) with a new Additional Costs Allowance, providing “targeted financial support where disability-related extra costs are well established, significant and ongoing”, alongside support for one-off expenses.

The proposed value of the Additional Costs Allowance is not outlined, but it is expected to be available to fewer people than PIP.

Headway UK calls on the government to guarantee that assessors for any replacement benefits receive adequate training to understand the often hidden, complex and fluctuating effects of brain injury that already make it difficult for those affected to get the support they need.

PIP and Universal Credit are lifelines for many young brain injury survivors both in and out of work. Any changes must ensure that those who need financial support do not lose out.

Youth Opportunity Service

Central to the Milburn recommendations is a proposed legal right for young people to have a route into education, training or work, supported by a new Youth Opportunity Service.

This would be a locally led service in England, giving young people a named adviser to support them into work, education or training.

How this would work in practice remains to be seen, but advisers must receive appropriate brain injury training to ensure survivors are properly supported. This service should also include targeted funding for vocational rehabilitation and investment in community-based reablement for brain injury survivors.

Severe and Complex Needs Insurance

Milburn also recommends introducing Severe and Complex Needs Insurance for people with profound and long-term disabilities who are assessed as being highly unlikely ever to work.

Payments would be set above the maximum benefit rates available today, with clinical, education and care evidence used to determine eligibility for those requiring continuous, 24-hour care and support

Headway UK welcomes the review’s recognition that for some brain injury survivors, employment will not be possible and that they should receive long-term financial security rather than pressure to work though we need to understand what this will mean in practice.

Headway UK Chief Executive Luke Griggs, said:

“These recommendations have the potential to improve opportunities for young brain injury survivors to get into work or education. But this report does not set out how this would happen.

“Too many young people face the prospect of not being able to live the life they intended as a result of brain injury reshaping their futures. Too often, they are written off due to not having access to vocational rehabilitation that could help them to return to work or education.

“This has to change. We cannot accept any reforms designed to improve young people’s prospects that leave disabled young people financially worse off or without access to services that can help them regain independence.

“Brain injury can be complex, fluctuating and difficult to recognise. Specialist training must therefore be built into the Youth Opportunity Service and the assessment of any new disability benefits. Survivors with memory, cognitive or communication difficulties may also need additional help to navigate the new system and access the support to which they are entitled.

“Alongside this, we need sustained investment in vocational rehabilitation and specialist services, helping those who can return to work or education to do so.

“But not every brain injury survivor will be able to work. We therefore in principle welcome the ambition of the proposed Severe and Complex Needs Insurance though we await the detail of how this is going to work in practice.

“We also need to be extremely careful about creating different levels of welfare support for different age groups. Brain injury can happen to anyone at any stage of life, and financial support should reflect someone’s needs, not simply how old they are.

“Ultimately, any reform must be judged on whether it improves support and opportunities without leaving brain injury survivors worse off.”

The Milburn review is independent, but Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden welcomed its publication, announcing a new youth opportunities unit and publication of relevant legislation in 2027. Its recommendations come ahead of the Timms review into the future of PIP as a whole.

While mainly focused on England, welfare and tax changes could have funding implications across government in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.